Skip to main content

Best key lime pie in Hamburg, NY.

A Bright Slice of Comfort
Key Lime Pie for a Sweet Finish

Key Lime Pie for a Sweet Finish

Key lime pie brings a lively citrus finish to a comforting meal, with creamy filling and a crisp crumb crust in every slice. Its balance of tart lime and gentle sweetness pairs well with diner favorites, a sub sandwich, or a plate of waffles. Add a slice after wraps or Greek-inspired dishes when you’re ready for a cool, refreshing dessert.
Delivery and Pickup Made Easy

Delivery and Pickup Made Easy

Enjoy a relaxed meal at home with delivery or choose pickup when it suits your plans. Add key lime pie to your order alongside comfort-food favorites, wraps, sandwiches, or waffles for a sweet finish. Whether you’re sharing dinner with family or grabbing a quick meal, ordering ahead makes it easy to bring home the dishes and dessert you’re craving.

Our location

Map showing the location of Pegasus restaurant on 5748 South Park Ave in Hamburg
Loading today's hours...